Butta On...
Music, Movies, Mass Media, Men & Other Madness
Wednesday, January 04, 2006
Butta On...Black Literary Filth Flarn Filth
There is a great Op-Ed piece in today's New York Times written by author Nick Chiles about the state of Black literature. I'll wait a few minutes while you go take a gander and come back (registration may be required).

Their Eyes Were Reading Smut

Done? Great.

My, my, my. Tell 'em why you mad, son! What can I say that Nick Chiles hasn't already say? He had me at "smut."

As an avid reader and oft-frustrated unpublished writer who has seen the pendulum swing from "sistagirl" lit to street lit over the past ten plus years, I feel his pain. Every time I go into my local Borders to see what's new, my literary sensibilities are assaulted by display upon rack upon shelf of half-naked broads who told Victoria's Secret; or screwfaced dudes waving guns, knives, or other weaponry at me; or garish book covers with expensive cars or tons of ice. If I wanted to see all that I'd stay up and watch BET Uncut.

Another friend who writes and I discussed this over email today, and it is truly a sad state of affairs. She recently went to her local Borders and they had no copies of Ellison's Invisible Man, only had Their Eyes Were Watching God as if Zora wrote nothing else, and she couldn't find any Black poetry books. But please believe she got an eyeful of the Baby Mama Drama Queen's G-Spot. Give. Me. A. Break.

There are people who argue that this trend is a good one because at least Black people are reading regardless of what we are reading. I'm sorry but when people (especially younger readers) can rattle off the titles, character names, and plot lines of every Nikki Vickie Teri Turner Stringer Woods novel but can't tell you what James Baldwin, Richard Wright, or Dorothy West wrote--much less who they are--then, Houston, we have a major problem.

I've been telling people for years that Black publishing is the new music industry. Just like how that putrid garbage otherwise known as "Laffy Taffy" and the gangsta's gangsta 50 Cent rise to the top of the charts, their literary equivalents are flying off the shelves and vendor tables. All flash, cash, sass, and ass and very little to no substance. Is it any wonder that 50 Cent signed a book publishing deal to create G-Unit Books under the Simon & Schuster umbrella in order to cash in on the new hustle?

Well, let me stop complaining and get back to writing my novel Smack It! Flip It! Rub It Down!: A Thrillogy. Hey, if you can't beat join 'em. Right? A sista's tryna get paid, too.
24 Comments:
Blogger SimplyDiva said...
Girl you ain't neva lied. I keep saying that I'm going to write a book for the professional black woman who doesn't give a care about hood chicks, gang bangers, or baby mamas and daddies.

Blogger Pammie said...
I'm glad someone spoke on this. I'm at the mall and I see YOUNG girls just buying Zane. and those crown publishing books.

I get fustrated that so many of us take the stance at least they are reading - we take that damn stance about everything! We are some of the most punkish of our race (speaking of our generation0 and I'm ashamed that noone - myself included will take a stand about anything! Videos, casual sex, empty reading - nothing!

Aww damn nose bleed again from being up on the podium...excuse me while I go blow........

Blogger Supa said...
Don't join 'em sis...the trend will swing back soon, or at least closer to the middle....

Blogger Nemesis said...
It pains me that black authors are relegated to writing one of three things: church novels (either set in a church or nonfiction by a church official); sistagirl novels (e.g Terry, Eric Jerome Dickey, E. Lynn); or street fiction. True voices (including Tananarive Due and Brandon Massey, for starters) don't get much love from publishers because the black readership "doesnt' read horror or sci-fi" [Octavia Butler notwithstanding]. Jesus put his head down and bawled.

*rubbing ears*

Woo-saaa...woooooooo-saaaaaaaa...

Butta Butta Butta....speak on it! It is getting harder and harder to find a quality read. I REFUSED to read Zane..folk swore she was the truffus and I cried big salty tears when that damn four dimes and two nickels announced his publishing deal - I CAN'T TAKE IT -I WON'T TAKE IT!

You know you wrong for that title...LMBAO!

Blogger Pammie said...
I would like to say that I have nothing against Zane or anyone who is excerising their 'right' to express themselves - but what does that say about where we are in our mental state?

Our story does need to be told - and unfortunately these types of books are a part of our story but it seems to me that we have decided from our music to our literature that this is the extent of our story. Which speaks alot like I said before about what we have on our minds and how it has become so easy to just say 'do you'. What is doing you is costing us our future?

Blogger Honey-Libra said...
You know I just thought about it and you are correct. Over the holidays I went to buy a black poetry book for my co-worker but I noticed I couldn't find one....I should have said something but during the hustle and bustle I forgot glad someone has said something. I love my "smut" fiction (lol) just like anyone else but sometimes a sister has to feel like she is learning something more than how to rob a bank. Good post

Blogger Genesis said...
oh my gawd...u 2 crazy. i gotta co-sign that shit. i mean i cant get into all those books like that. sure black folks are reading...but they arent gaining anything from it.

they live in the hood
they go to the school in the hood
their friends live in the hood.
they watch movies,
listen to music,
and read books about the hood
what do they know outside of the hood? nothing.

the books writing thing is a new hustle for black folks from the hood...specifically women who dont have college degrees since they arent succeeding that well in anything else.

Blogger Beauty said...
LMAO!! You know the worst that I heard? I heard some people call Karrine Steffans (Supahead) a writer. See these are signs that these are our last days.

Blogger Zantiferous3 said...
Girl please... the books that are out now are truly a sign of the clearly imminent Apocalypse. *sigh*

But sweetie this is NOT a new phenomenon. Umm.. does the name Donald Goines ring a bell? Please when I was in high schoool, his books were all the rage. While I was on the bus reading "Song of Solomon" these fools were reading "Whoreson" and "My Daddy Was a Number Runner" *sigh* girl ignorance knows no generation. This has been a problem for quite some time. And shoot, if WHAT we're reading shouldn't matter, then we're ALL avid literature buffs, with all the interstate signs and subway maps we read daily. Get the hell outta here, of COURSE it matters. Zane is NOT freaking literature. Dammit Eric Jerome Dickey is not educational. *sigh* We're always so content with aiming so damn low... *sigh* another reason we can't rise as a people. As Panama would say... 'we ain't gonna make it." LOL

Blogger TJ said...
I read that piece earlier today. The reference you made to the publishing world being a mirror image of the music industry was dead on. The bad part about this is that people used to outgrow this "street" phase and now you see 40- and 50-year-old folk who can't let it go. Maybe it is the beginning of the end.

Blogger solitaire said...
I'm with Joy. Supahead isn't an "author". That's not "literature".

PREACH BUTTA...PREACH IT LOUD, IYAH! I love reading but I can't take this attack on our people. Jesus help us!! Chuh man! (kisses teeth)

Blogger Tiger Lilly said...
The phenomenon is really disheartening, but it's older than you know. There have been moments in publishing history where the only things that were "base" novels. This started in the 19th century with serial novels that were targeting the working class. The best thing those books did was allow a class of people who had previously been denied the opportunity to learn (read) and engage in something that was previously deemed above their station. THere is no real difference here, other than the fact that someone somewhere should have told the people who are buying this "product" that, well, it's shitty. Hmmm, that literature degree couldn't get me a good job, but I do know useless info on the history of publishing.

Blogger Miss Ahmad said...
girl, although i don't know you i feel like you are speaking my language! I have had near breakdowns in the "black" book section, making me wonder why i keep blogging and don't just finish my damn book!

Blogger Urban Sista said...
Girl! I HEAR you. In Canada, we have African-American/Black book tables in our large bookstores and you'll have to search long and hard for worthwhile things to read.

I'm not saying everyone has to write literature, but can't commercial fiction be good? Can't it have a good plot? Character development? Instead of formula crap that just makes you want to re-read the old stuff? Chupse.

Blogger Anacaona said...
Wow. I must say that I don't even know the black authors you mentioned because I have only read Terry Mcmillan and Connie Briscoe and Virginia DeBerry etc. Very popular authors. I am glad you listed ones I can read, I have stayed away from a lot of them for this very reason that the article mention. What really makes me laugh is when people have nerve to call themselves a book club and the book is one of those ghetto novels!!!

Hurry up and get published Butta, I'm ready to read.

Blogger Arriet Till said...
Sorry I'm late on this but I just wanted to add that I don't even visit the black book sections in the library or bookstores at all anymore.

I really thought I was one of the only people with this frame of mind as it seems all of my co-workers and friends read this garbage like its the New Testament.

The question is how do we turn the tide?

Blogger Cocoa Girl said...
OMGosh girl...you're off the hook with the "Smack it Up, Flip It..."

I too feel your pain. Every since I began writing, I've felt as though I should write to save the race, per se. These books are always in some neon color (as if black people only like brite sh!t) and absolutely ridiculous. I live in Harlem and visit 125th St everyday to go the gym and, everyday, I have to walk by this crap. Not to diss all of the street lit folks, but I was so glad when my agent told me that she doesn't do it and eluded to (w/ zero regret) the fact that she was approached first to rep a certain tell-all, sex memoir that was guaranteed to be a hit, but turned it down. I swear that had to be one of her biggest selling points.

This madness has got to end. Your comment about how the publishing industry is the new music industry is sad but true. Damn.

Blogger Berry said...
I chimed in over on Dominique's page but you brought up a couple addition points. This seems to be the age old debate of classic lit. vs. pop culture which naturally isn't exclusively a black issue. Of course, it is imperitive that as black people who have already faced centuries of cultural destruction it must be dealt with...but how???

Blogger Stephen Bess said...
Literature...what literature?

Blogger chase said...
my sister have been talking about this now forever! I thought we were the only ones...cause everyone else is reading that crap and lovin it.

AMEN! I feel bamboozled everytime I go into my local Barnes & Nobles and Borders - book stores. I literally have to put in a 'special' order for any books of substance! I was shocked to find how much nonsense they stock in the store but we can't get any real literary pieces! Argh!

What are we gonna do?

p.s. - love your blog!!

Blogger city_boi said...
Well u all have some extremely vaild points. BUT what none of u are doing is saying what SHOULD black authors be writing about...? U don't want 'Laffy Taffy' fiction well fine. (I really am with you on this) But all I'm hearing is criticism, but I'm not seeing any suggestions. I'm thinking your all should keep your criticism to yourself... UNLESS you can offer some helpful, upbuilding, positive alternatives. And I'm not saying this to be harsh, nor am I angry at anyone who's posted, it's just that what's being said so far isn't contructive. You's have only torn down with your words... you're only venting. No one here has said anything to really build up or give direction to 'mis-guided' young writers who may not know what they could be doing differnt... Ya'll feel me...? :)

Blogger city_boi said...
P.S. Sorry for my misspellings. I should have used spell check...lol.

I'm luvin your BLOG too Ms. Lady...